K/R: EF coat (Keeping)

One of my recent Rack finds on clearance, this sort of a trench coat. It is very plain and sleek with magnetic closures, not even buttons. It is completely reversible, but I would probably wear the olive side (#1-3) most. The reverse is a bone white. (#4-5). Also good with my wardrobe. Both sides have pockets at the side.
What do you say? Keep or return?

This post is also published in the youlookfab forum. You can read and reply to it in either place. All replies will appear in both places.


  • Jenni NZ replied 5 months ago

    Keep! Looks amazing! I like both sides but would also wear the olive more, I love olive, prob my second favourite colour after cobalt currently.

  • JAileen replied 5 months ago

    Keep! I love reversible things, and I think both colors look good on you. Plus EF, so probably great quality.

  • nemosmom replied 5 months ago

    Oooh I vote keep! Love how versatile the two colors are. It looks like it fits you well, too!

  • MsMaven replied 5 months ago

    Keep! Stunning on you.

  • Angie replied 5 months ago



  • viva replied 5 months ago

    I love it - both sides. What a fantastic find! Keep!!!

  • Sal replied 5 months ago

    I like it too Joy- both sides look great.

  • rachylou replied 5 months ago

    Oh gosh. I really really like it! Fashion plate with the cute shoes!

  • Joy replied 5 months ago

    I am thrilled this coat gets YLF approval and rates a KILLER from Angie. I have nothing like it and it is perfect for a bit a chill in the air. JAileen, it seems well designed and great quality.

  • Jane replied 5 months ago


  • Sterling replied 5 months ago

    Fits you extremely well.  

  • Lucy replied 5 months ago

    Absolutely love it on you! Winner, both in style and fit. Amazing find. 

  • bonnie replied 5 months ago

    I agree that you should keep. You are on a roll.

  • Windchime replied 5 months ago

    Glad to read you plan to keep it, and extra fab that it’s reversible! Both colors look wonderful on you. Cute pants, too.

  • Joy replied 5 months ago

    I am so happy that I can cut the tags. This week looks like it will have lots of rain and highs on the 50’s and 60’s F, so it will get some wear.
    Windchime, the pants are some consignment olive utility pants that I was given to wear in a store fashion show. Wait ‘til you see the light weight poncho that was worn with them. It is still too cold to wear now.

  • shevia replied 4 months ago

    Keep! I like the contrast around the collar in both directions, and it looks great on you!

  • Gigi replied 4 months ago

    This looks great! What a fab find. I vote keep.

  • lisa p replied 4 months ago

    I want this!  Looks fantastic on you !  What are the booties you are wearing in the pics with the off-white side out of the coat?

  • celia replied 4 months ago

    That looks amazing on you! Please keep it.

  • Joy replied 4 months ago

    Thank you for more love for the new coat. Lisa, the booties are another Rack find that at $12.( 50% off clearance) I will keep. They are waterproof soft suede Cole Haans and super warm and comfortable. See my thread on the Nordstrom Rack clearance sale. I brought home way too many boots..

  • suntiger replied 4 months ago

    Ditto Angie!

  • Inge replied 4 months ago

    Sooo glad you are keeping the coat, Joy! It looks fantastic!! And I love those booties in the last photo too!

  • Glory replied 4 months ago

    Amazing on you and keep without a doubt. I love both colours! I also now want it :)

  • Murph11 replied 4 months ago

    Amazing jacket, Joy! What a score!


  • Katerina replied 4 months ago

    It looks great on you, glad you keep it. Both colours are fabulous. How fun it is reversible.

  • kkards replied 4 months ago

    Keep! love this...and it's a 2fer...

  • lisa p replied 4 months ago

    What do you mean $12?  Great score!

  • Mirjana replied 4 months ago

    Great coat Joy, especially for this rainy summer, we have rain almost every day.

  • Opaline replied 4 months ago

    Positively a keeper!

  • Elizabeth P replied 4 months ago

    LOVE!  KEEP!

  • Brooklyn replied 4 months ago

    Absolutely keep!

  • Joy replied 4 months ago

    Yes, I am keeping it and the boots in the last photo. Thank you, ladies, for your help in helping me to decide. You are The Best!

  • unfrumped replied 4 months ago

    Of course keep!
    How amazing it’s reversible in 2 colors that work great for you. I didn’t know EF did things like that.

  • Windchime replied 4 months ago

    JOY, you were part of a store fashion show?! Congratulations; that must have been fun. Now I want to see the poncho. :)

  • RobinF replied 4 months ago

    I'm happy you are keeping - love it! 

  • karen13 replied 4 months ago

    Joy - Just gorgeous on you. Sleek and so versatile. Love the light side out with your coloring.

  • Lucy replied 4 months ago

    Keep for sure!

You need to be logged in to comment